Are Kids More Creative Than Adults? – Ep. 238
January 23, 2023
Listen Now:
In the special segment “Internet Insanity,” Shanna and Laura share the wackiest parenting-related things they’ve come across online recently, including the surprising new trend in baby showers, a questionable study about kids and creativity and more! Also, Shanna reports on the adorably over-the-top holiday recital her four-year-old performed in, and Laura talks about her four-year-old’s first trip to the snow. Finally, they share their BFPs and BFNs for the week. Shanna’s kids are 4 and 6 years old, and Laura’s kids are 3.5 years old and 22 months old.
Want to get in touch? Send us an email and follow us on social! Instagram, Facebook or TikTok at @bfppodcast
This episode’s show notes can be found here.
Join our Facebook community group for support and camaraderie on your parenting journey.
Visit our website!
Big Fat Positive: A Pregnancy and Parenting Journey is produced by Laura Birek, Shanna Micko and Steve Yager.
Show Notes:
- FeverAll Acetaminophen Suppositories* Laura found these acetaminophen suppositories very helpful for her 1 year old when he was sick with a stomach bug.
- Article about Grandma Showers by Cassie Morris. This is the article about Grandma showers that Shanna talks about in the episode.
- Tiktok from @passionland.co Tiktok about creativity in kids that Laura mentions in the show.
- Article in Scary Mommy about Grandma that ranks her grandkids by Krystal Martinez. Shanna talks about the TikTok user whose Grandma has a ranking system for her grandkids.
- TikTok from @gesikaaaaaa This video about a mom sending her son inside the house to unlock the front door impressed Laura and Shanna.
(*denotes affiliate link)
Episode Gallery
This episode's sponsors:
Whisker Litter-Robot
Litter-Robot is the world’s best automatic self-cleaning litter box. And just for listening to Big Fat Positive, you can save an extra $50 on bundles! Just use BFP at checkout.
Once Upon a Dance
Once Upon a Dance INSPIRES JOYFUL MOVEMENT through stories that celebrate CONNECTION, IMAGINATION & GRACE.
Episode Transcript
Laura
Welcome to Big Fat Positive with Shanna and Laura. This week we have our weekly check-ins, we have our special segment, Internet Insanity, where we talk about creative kids and grandmas with grudges, and we close with our BFPs and BFNs for the week. Let's get started!
Hi, everyone. Welcome to the show. This is episode 238. Hi, Shanna. Hi. I just want to say that it is raining outside and it's a little loud. So if you guys hear a pitter patter out there, it's not little feet. It is raindrops falling on our heads. Well, that's good. That's a relaxing background sound, right? Oh, it is. I actually really love it. I haven't been listening to music. I've just been sitting, like, listening to the rain. I love that. I know. But right now, I do want to listen to the soothing sounds of your voice, Shanna, because I want to hear what's been going on with your week.
Shanna
Literally, no one's ever described my voice as soothing, so I'll take that thing.
Laura
What are you talking about? Okay, listeners, please write in and reassure Shanna that she has a very soothing, wonderful voice. Maybe I'll start a meditation podcast. Yeah, or an ASMR.
Shanna
Oh, yeah, yeah, my new side hobby.
OK, here we go. Here are my chickens. So this week was all about getting ready for the holidays. Elle already started her winter break, so she was home all week. I still, of course, had to work most of the week. So a lot of her time is just kind of hanging out watching TV and playing on the iPad. You know, she's living her best life. She loves it. Yeah. But the big event this week, I've mentioned it before on the show, Laura was CeCe's Christmas recital at her preschool.
Laura
Oh, the one with the strict dress code.
Shanna
Yes, where the boys had to wear Christmas bow ties.
Laura
Yes, everyone in their Christmas bow ties, they just reached in their drawer and got them.
Shanna
Yeah. So we got official tickets to the performance. They were very fancy. And we got there early and got a terrible seat. We were way in the back. We could barely see the stage. I was so pissed. But it was so adorable. It was equally adorable and chaotic. I mean, it was packed. There were probably over 200 parents, grandparents, siblings, I mean, tons of babies all in this ballroom area. And there was a little stage set up and every little class paraded in and they're matching Christmas attire. It was so cute. The little two-year-olds, I don't think they actually sang a word. They just kind of stood there staring like deer eyes out at the audience while the music played. Oh my God, it was so cute. So for Cece's outfit, right, she had to wear like a white dress and a red headpiece and all this jazz. So I sourced it from my local Buy Nothing group. I borrowed a dress from someone here.
I'll show you a picture of her recital outfit. I just sent you a photo.
Laura
Okay, let me see. Oh my goodness. She looks so chic. She's got like this. I mean, I think it could double as like a communion dress on.
Shanna
That's what it was. It was the neighbor's daughter's communion dress. Yes.
Laura
I mean, that why else would anyone in the right mind own a white dress for a toddler? Like truly.
Shanna
I know, right? It's not in our repertoire. A terrible idea.
Laura
White. I will barely buy shirts that have like little bits of white on them. Right? And she also has like a faux fur. stole kind of over her shoulders. Oh yes, her little shrug, because it was a cold day. Or shrug, that's the word I'm looking for. Oh my goodness. And of course, you got the headband. She looks so put together and she looks really sweet. Did she like wearing the dress?
Shanna
Yeah, she did actually. I was really nervous because I have very casual kids, very casual kids. But she was pretty jazzed about wearing that outfit and getting dressed up and everything. Um, so she looked very fancy on stage with her friends and, you know, she's in like the three and four year old class. They're a little bit older and I could tell they practiced a lot, uh, cause they were all actually singing along. Some of them more enthusiastically than others.
Oh my God, when Sisi's class got on stage, I had a bad seat, right? I was mentioning I had a bad seat. I couldn't really see. I was ruthless. I did not, and shameless. I did not even care. I was like, oh, come with me. And the two of us went up in the middle of the aisle, like the walkway between the seats and like Crouched down on the floor in front of the stage so I could get video and actually see her face It was kind of embarrassing, but like I'm like I don't care man.
Laura
I want to see my kid I mean why else are you there like truly what so you can be in the back and not see your own kid when they're performing And you have to sit through a bunch of two-year-old staring into the void
Shanna
So I got a little bit of footage. I'll send you a little video so you can get the vibe of what was happening. Oh yeah, I want the vibe. All right, sending it your way. Okay, let's see.
Laura
Oh my God, they're so cute. See, she's on it. She's playing with her bow on her waist a little bit, her little belt, but she's still singing. Yeah. Yeah. The little boys in their bow ties are extremely cute, I have to say. I get why they required that. It's adorable.
Shanna
Yeah.
Laura
Oh my gosh, and they're singing Jingle Bells. Adorable.
Shanna
Yeah. So, so much cuteness. And I was really proud of her. I didn't know how she would be performing in front of everybody, you know, because I just don't know her style yet. Like with Elle, I'm like, oh yeah, Elle goes all out on stage, right? And I'm like, how is Cece going to be? But yeah, she was definitely participating, singing along, a little nervous, I could tell, because she was like fiddling with her outfit and stuff. She powered through the nervousness and did really well. And I was so happy.
Laura
Awesome. I'm so glad that worked out.
Shanna
Yeah. And then a couple of days later was Christmas Eve. And I just like want to say that last year I had not a lot of Christmas spirit. I remember talking about this on the show. Like I'd had a tough run with like Chili dying and Elbin in the hospital. And I was just drained, right? And I didn't come into Christmas with a lot of joy and enthusiasm, but This year I came in hard with it. I was like, super excited to celebrate and my mother-in-law was in town and we made cookies and we made these little lanterns. My mother-in-law put together this craft for us and we had a wonderful Christmas Eve. Let me just send you a couple pictures of some of our activities.
Laura
Okay, I see the whole Yager clan hanging out. Oh, is that a lantern or a drink in your hand? We made little lanterns out of mugs. I see, like glass mugs. Oh, very cool. Very festive. The girls are having fun. It looks like Sissy's holding up some kind of gingerbread man shape. Is that a cookie or a crab? Yeah, very adorable. Oh, Elle is about to chomp down. on a Christmas cookie shaped like a Christmas tree. Well, this looks festive AF, Shanna.
Shanna
Yeah, it was. So we've been having wonderful holiday vibes all around. And yeah, that's pretty much my check-in. Awesome. How about you, if your kids started the holiday break, or what are you up to this week?
Laura
Yes, yes. So Augie has started his holiday break. His school takes two and a half weeks off. And Sebastian actually, his school only takes two days off throughout the holiday. I know. I mean, it's amazing.
Shanna
A parent's dream.
Laura
It is. So the only days they take off are would be next week, the day after Christmas, and then the following week, the day after New Year's. And it's the day after because this year they're both Sundays, right? However, he did not make it the whole week this week, Shanna.
Shanna
No. Yeah. Sick again.
Laura
Ugh. He got a stomach bug and it's not a good one, Shanna. This poor baby, he's still really sick. I think he's gonna be sick through Christmas. He's been kind of been up and down, right? So on Wednesday night after dinner, he was like chewing on his finger. I think his back molars might be coming in, right? And so he was chewing on his finger and he kept sticking his finger on the back of his throat, right? And gagging. Oh boy, that's fun. Yeah, and we were like, stop it, stop it. But he thought it was funny, right? You know, anytime you say stop it to him, he thinks you're joking. Like he's such a fucking joker, this baby. Like all he wants to do is make jokes and like tease you and taunt you. So I was like, no, no, no, that's bad gagging you. You're going to throw up. Stop it. And he was like, what this, you know, and he was like doing it more.
And so he ended up throwing up that night. And I was like, well, he gagged himself, right? That's nothing, right? And then he was fine after that, completely fine. So we didn't even think that it was anything other than that. Until the next day, Thursday, we get a text message from his teachers around nap time saying, Sebastian's just thrown up. We're going to keep an eye on him. And then I was like, oh, shit. I'm like, was last night not a fluke? You know? But I didn't want to be like, well, he threw up last night, but we still sent him into school because I don't want them to think I'm a monster. Naturally. I want them to think highly of me. So I was just like, oh, weird. Well, keep us posted. And then like 10 minutes later, it's like, okay, he threw up again. So you're going to need to come get him. And I was like, Come on. I wasn't planning on having both kids home until next week.
And I was just like, okay. So of course we felt bad for him. So we went and we got him. And the poor baby, I immediately nursed him, tried to make him feel better. And then he puked that up. And he just was not keeping anything down. Anything, anything, anything. Give him a popsicle that came back up. Like he was sick. So I felt awful for him. It was just so hard to see. Let me, I'm going to send you a picture of the sad baby.
Shanna
Oh, okay.
Laura
He was just like falling asleep everywhere.
Shanna
Oh, this picture is so sad. He's asleep in your arms and he looks sick. He does like dark circles under his eyes. Oh, baby. I know the poor thing.
Laura
you look sad to i'm not gonna lie i was really sad for him i was it's so hard to see your children sick you know like all you want to do is protect them and stomach bugs especially are really hard because like i don't know there's a lot of You can't really give them medicine because they throw it up. And it's just really hard to comfort them, except for just to literally hold them. I'm going to send one more picture that I just found.
Shanna
Aw, the brothers together. Augie looks happy, but Sebastian looks miserable.
Laura
Oh, his little pout. And we were trying to keep Augie away from Sebastian a little bit to hopefully have him knock at the stomach bug. Yeah, but it's impossible with a almost two-year-old and almost four-year-old like it just it There's no keeping them apart and all they fucking do is steal each other's water bottles. It's just like endless So anyway, I'm just holding my breath for Augie to get sick too, but Poor Sebastian as of right now he's kind of on an update but it's been up and down like I'm not holding my breath I will say one thing we did find which really helped was something called fever all have you ever used fever all no they are acetaminophen or Tylenol. suppositories for kids under the age of three. Oh, smart. And, you know, no pun that totally saved our ass. Because, you know, he did have a fever.
He was like, he had like, I don't know, my head, forehead thermometer thing is super inaccurate. But it was reading like 101, 102. Like he had like a legit fever. And he was miserable and we couldn't give him any oral medicines because they just came right back up. So the suppositories really, really helped. Like that was the main thing that helped him feel better. So if anyone's in the same situation, I highly recommend them. Also, I think there's still like a Tylenol shortage or people are just buying it out on the shelves. Like children's Tylenol is super hard to find, but that was like in stock, no problem. So. Oh, good. Hot tip. So yeah, so him being sick really sucked. And it also kind of screwed up some of our festive plans that we had, which was we had promised Augie that on Friday we were going to drive up to the mountains and take him to see snow. Oh, fun.
But yeah, sick baby, that's not going to work. Yeah, we're not going on any winding mountain roads with that baby in that picture. He's so sad and tired. However, Augie has been anxiously anticipating this trip to the snow for weeks. Have I shown you any pictures of him with his snow gear? No, he has snow gear. Oh my god. Okay, so Corey. It was like, let's go to the snow with the kids when they're off school for, you know, before Christmas. And I was like, okay, great idea. And then he was like, okay, let's do it. And then I realized that it was on me to like spend the next few weeks sourcing snow gear for the kids because like it's not like we have.
Stuff for them so i frantically search to know by nothing and my mom's groups and stuff getting all the snow gear for them and it kept arriving at the house like i pick up a snow bib or i pick up some new snow boots from target and as it arrived hockey was just like. So excited about all of it like he all he wanted to do is wear it to the point where he was literally wearing his snow gear to school on like 65 degree days. I'm gonna send you a picture.
So I sent you a picture.
Shanna
Oh my gosh, he is decked out head to toe. He looks like he belongs in Minnesota. This big puffy jacket with this big hood and thick mittens.
Laura
Oh, he's ready for the snow. He's ready. So Cory and I on Thursday are looking at each other with this like sick baby who like will not even wake up in my arms. I mean, he wasn't that, but like he wasn't on death's doorstep. But you know what I mean? Like he's so tired. He's so sick. And I'm like, I can't take this baby to the snow. And Cory's like, are you going to tell Augie? What are we going to do? And that's when I was like, you guys need to go. I know I want to be there for Augie's first real snow, but I can't tell him you're not going. I'm like, you and Augie go together tomorrow. You have a daddy Sunday, and I'll just stay home with sick baby. And so that's what they did. Despite me not being there, it looked like they had a wonderful day. They went up to Mountain High, which is a ski area near us. I've never been to.
And they have like a snow play area for kids and like a sledding area. And Cory was sending me pictures throughout the day. And the kid was so freaking happy. Oh my gosh. Oh, how fun. Oh, and they got to take a ski lift? Oh, fun. So they had a really wonderful day, and I'm really glad for that. I was sad to miss it, but I was just more happy that at least Augie got to do it, and he got to go be in the snow and experience it for real. Okay, I sent you some pictures that Corey had sent to me while I was at home with the sick baby. All right, let's see.
Shanna
Oh boy.
posing with some kind of snow yeti with a big candy cane. That's very exciting. Oh, he looks so happy just tromping through the snow in a big sled. That's that's very cool. Like an inner tube sled.
Laura
OK, I just sent you a video of him going down this inner tube run.
Shanna
All right, let's see. Oh, my gosh. First of all, that looks fun as hell. I want to be in that position. Second, I'm impressed that he's alone in there, like doing that by himself without Corey. Very, very impressive.
Laura
Yeah. I mean, he's a thrill seeker, so it doesn't surprise me. I saw the video and I was like, um, is this a safe choice? So yeah, I mean, I'm bummed that I missed it, but they had so much fun. And I'm sure Augie really enjoyed having that one-on-one time with his dad. So there's silver linings there. And I'm just hoping Sebastian is feeling better by Christmas. Me too, sending him all the healthy healing vibes. Thanks, thanks. But anyway, I think it might be time to move on to our special segment. What do you think? Oh, yes, indeed.
Shanna
We're back, and this week's special segment is Internet Insanity, where we report on the interesting, fascinating, hilarious things we've found online recently regarding parenting. Laura, you are up first, and I'm so curious to know what your first Internet Insanity is.
Laura
Okay, so my first one is something I found on TikTok, surprise, surprise.
Shanna
I have to say TikTok has done wonders for our internet and sanity segment.
Laura
Truly. Right? Where would we be? Where would this segment be without the glory of TikTok? We'd have to be talking about Facebook?
Shanna
I mean, ew.
Laura
Come on. I'm actually joking. I love our Facebook group. But yes, no, TikTok is great. So I'm going to send you this video so you can see it, and then we'll talk about it.
Shanna
All right. Well, this is interesting. OK, Laura, tell our listeners about this, and then let's discuss.
Laura
So this TikTok was from a creator, passionland.co. And it was about a study that was conducted in the late 60s by George Land and Beth Jarman about creative genius and age. So like, whether young children are more creative than older children, basically. So the study used supposedly the same test that was given to like NASA engineers to determine their level of creative genius. And they found that out of five year olds, 98% of them tested as creative geniuses.
Shanna
Oh my gosh. This is why I'm afraid of kindergartners. They're brilliant.
Laura
And then they say by age 10, it goes down to 30%. And they repeated it and found that by the time we're adults, only 2% of us qualify as quote unquote creative geniuses. Oh my gosh. But Shanna, this is an internet insanity segment. This is not a today I learned segment. True. True. So in that light, I'm here to tell you it's all lies. Wait, what? This this TikTok, this what are you talking about? All of it, Shanna. This study apparently never happened. OK. So I saw this and I was like, this seems like too good, right? Like this seems too clear and also like 1968's a long time ago to be doing these kind of tests like I don't know my spiny sense of like this is bullshit was I guess you'd call it like my bullshit meter was it was tingling right. You've got a good bullshit. Well you know what I'm starting to like.
realize that a lot of the claims that are made in these little summary videos and stuff aren't always like verifiable, right? And you know why I think I'm starting to realize that is not just because it's sort of like it's starting to be in the zeitgeist a little bit. I feel like there's that new podcast. This book will kill you. I love it.
Shanna
It's so good. Yeah.
Laura
And like that's all they do basically is they're like, This is all bullshit, right? I had just been listening to that podcast and I was like, this smacks of, you know, something you read in an airport book and you think like, oh, amazing. And then it turns out there's nothing behind it, right? So I started digging. Yes. And yeah, it's repeated all over the place, including a TEDx talk, right? And I think people have really latched onto it because it sounds like such a cool idea, right? Like you hear it and you're like, oh, that kind of makes sense, right? Like my kids are so creative and so interesting. And as adults, you feel like you've lost it, right? Like you've lost something. And so that reinforces it. But this author, Emile Kierkegaard, did this deep dive into it because his bullshit spidey sense was also tingling.
And it turns out that he could not find anywhere anything to support this claim. Okay, so this kindred spirit and meal did a lot of digging through like scholarly research and databases. And he could not find any evidence that the study even happened in the first place. And he found additional studies that actually did happen, including a meta-analysis of a bunch of other studies that measured what they call divergent thinking, DT, which is basically creative thinking. in people of different ages that totally contradicts this thing. It says that it actually increases as kids get older. Like it was a steady upward trend through grades.
Shanna
Interesting.
Laura
Yeah, steady upward trend through grades one through 12. And he said the meta analysis of adults found that creativity generally tops in early mid adulthood, which is expected based on like what we know about brain development. Okay. So not only could he not find any source for this supposed NASA study that they did, But he also found conflicting information that actually is in line with like what we know about the brain. And so his conclusion is, children are not creativity geniuses. The available evidence shows that creative thinking tests show the usual age pattern seen with other cognitive tests. George Land's claim is totally contrary to other research and there is no evidence it exists. It is likely that George Land made it up.
Shanna
Why? Why? Why do people spread misinformation and about something so benign, like creativity and kids? What is the motivation there?
Laura
I mean, he probably just needed like a paragraph for his book, you know? Yeah. Cause that's one thing he did find was like a mention of George Land in some book. And it's like, he probably just needed some kind of quote. And with the confidence of a mediocre white guy was just like, sure. Yeah, 98% of five year olds are creative geniuses. You know, like, oh, I can just say that no one will care. It's 1968. No one will have any way to verify this.
Shanna
Right. Right. But now we've got the internet and now we have ways of much more easily checking things.
Laura
But that TikTok I sent you has 301,000 views, Shanna.
Shanna
Of course it does. Did you come in hot in the comment section being like, nah, this is not right?
Laura
Ugh, I really wanted to, like, I'm such that person, right? I want to be like, but actually, which is such a, it's a bad impulse of mine, but like, someone should be like, hey, this is a lie. But it's so much harder to find the this is a lie information than to find like a hundred sources also citing this total bullshit. So yeah, I'm sure she's not the only person making a video about this. No, because we just trust. You saw it in a TED Talk. You think that it's fact-checked. It's not. The other thing I learned about from that This Book Will Kill You series is that nonfiction books don't get fact-checked. It's wild. So I write articles occasionally. And sometimes they're for like bigger magazines. Like the biggest one I've written for is probably O Magazine or Parents, right? Parents Magazine.
Oh, magazine, for example, that's I think at the time I was writing for it, it was the most popular women's magazine in the US. Huge distribution, right? Huge readership. And as such, they have a whole fact checking department. So when I would write something for them, my sources were getting calls to fact check like the quotes. I had to submit my transcripts of every interview I did. I had to submit contact information for everyone I talked to. It might be a little different if I was scooping some kind of top secret story and trying to keep my sources private, but I'm writing flowcharts about diaper rash. It's not top secret. But like every single thing was fact check and the fact checkers would come back to me sometimes with like miniscule things just to double check. So like I assumed that book publishers were doing the exact same thing.
They are not they are not doing that like you can basically publish whatever shit you want in a nonfiction book as far as I can tell. And so if something gets published in a book or put on a TEDx, unless you want to go and research every point that's made, people aren't doing that. People are regurgitating it for social media. I mean, we do the same thing. We have a Today I Learn segment. I try to do my due diligence when we do Today I Learn and really fact check things. Right. But, you know, like if I tried to fact check this for today, I learned and I didn't have the sense that it was fake. I don't know if I would have found this because I had to like search the authors, you know, George Land and Beth Jarman fake in order to get this, right? If I was just searching their names, I would have gotten the like hundreds of other pieces written that cite this imaginary study as real. So.
Oh, it's infuriating.
Shanna
And yeah, we're just fed these little tidbits on TikTok or wherever, you know, we watch them Instagram reels or whatever. And it's like, oh, that's fascinating. Double tap the heart and then move on. And then that little nugget lives in my brain as reality. And then I look at my kids and I'm like, oh, my God, they're so genius. And then I think about myself and I'm like, I'm a loser with no creativity. And then it just kind of like, it's insidious. It gets into my life and my head and it's messed up.
Laura
Turns out, you're more creative than your kids. Suck it, kids.
Speaker 1
Ha ha ha ha.
Laura
Or maybe you were ten years ago, I don't know. I know, it's all downhill from here. I tried to figure out what early, mid adulthood meant, and I couldn't quite figure that out. Yeah, probably not my age. Probably like 27. I feel pretty creative at 27. Yeah, me too. Anyway, that was my first Internet Insanity. Whoo, that was a good one. Shanna, I want to hear your first Internet Insanity. What have you seen on those webs, the interwebs, the series of tubes?
Shanna
I have discovered grandma showers.
Laura
What? I know, that sounds so... I'm inferring what it means now. At first I'm imagining grandma's taking a shower, okay. Do your kids take a shower with grandma like I can be okay and I mean some families whatever like whatever happened but that doesn't seem like what I'm like oh is this like a baby shower but for the grandma's.
Shanna
Yes, Laura, this is a new phenomenon happening. Oh my goodness. Wow, okay. Grandma showers are on the rise. I first came across this in an article from an online site called intheknow.com. And they were summarizing some Reddit drama, you know. Reddit's also good for the internet insanity. I love it. So this person who's pregnant goes to Reddit to complain that her mother-in-law had a baby shower for herself, for the grandmother. The mom of the actual child didn't know, wasn't invited, and found out about it when the grandma posted pictures of the shower online. She's like, there was a full buffet. There was a banner that read, it's a boy. Let's celebrate grandma pictures of the pregnant mom were like up at the shower.
Laura
Oh my God. Yeah, there's the line that's really been crying. I mean, yeah. Oh wow, okay.
Shanna
Yeah, so she wasn't invited, but she was there, I guess, in spirit or in photo form. So this got me thinking. I'm like, is this a one-off, like just a odd, like, you know, mother-in-law quirk thing she just decided to do for herself.
Laura
Wait, can I ask a question first? Like, so was she getting presents that she was then going to pass on? And she was receiving presents.
The point is to receive things that are useful for the baby. Is it so that she can watch the baby when they're busy? I had the same questions, Laura.
Shanna
I needed to know what is the deal with grandma showers. I started going down the internet rabbit hole to figure this out. It is not a deep rabbit hole. I literally googled grandma showers. And tons of articles come up like how to host a grandma shower. So I go into some article about grandma showers and like tips for hosting one and everything. And yeah, the idea is that grandma's grandma to be are having these parties so that their friends can get them gifts for the baby that they can keep at their house so that the baby can use it when the kid comes over. And like some of the people in the article are quoted like, well, I just don't have anything. I have nothing for, you know, the grand baby for when they come over. So yes, there's definitely a gifts element involved as well as celebrating becoming a grandma. And of course this comes with great controversy, right?
Some people think it's sweet, like celebrating grandma coming into grandmotherhood and, you know, I think that's sweet too. Why not? If you're like really close to your grandma and you actually invite the pregnant person along, I think maybe that could be a really special celebration.
Laura
I think at least, you know, giving the pregnant person a heads up this is happening is probably the first step to making it a sweet occasion and not like a weird one.
Shanna
Yeah, exactly. People are also seeing it as one-upping the pregnant mom, right? Like taking over the spotlight. Like, oh, this is all about me instead of the actual mom. So there's that. Some people are criticizing it as a gift grab. So, you know, some people think it's sweet. Some people think it's atrocious. I don't know. I think it all just depends on context personally.
Laura
Yeah, I could see it both ways. I mean, I think, like you said, it depends on how it's handled. Like, I absolutely would have been supportive of my mom or my mother-in-law having a grandma shower if it was like, A, you told me it was happening, and B, like, you know, it's for stuff so that you could help take care of the kids. Like, anything that helps me offload my children on the grandparents is just welcome. Yeah, truly let that grandma get a pack and play for her house. Sure. But I can see if you have somewhat of a more troubled relationship with your mom or your mother-in-law, this rubbing you the wrong way, for sure.
Shanna
For sure. If you do want to throw a grandma shower, there are plenty of resources online. There are lots of images of grandma ribbons. Apparently it's like a big thing. That's the number one thing that comes up when I search in the images, like a Like a best grandma ribbon. So I think maybe there's like some tradition blooming of like the grandma to be like gets past this like grandma ribbon and stuff. So if that's up your alley, there are tons of resources online for this new budding tradition.
Laura
You learn something new every day. Truly. Never heard about it until this very moment. Thank you, Shanna.
Shanna
You are welcome. All right, your turn again. What's your next internet insanity?
Laura
OK, so I did want to do two TikToks, but like what else am I doing with my time is the real question, right? So I am sending you another TikTok. I'd like you to watch. Yes. And I'm going to have you react to this. It's a little long, but I think you'll find it really funny. All right, here we go.
Speaker 1
All right, son.
We gave data our house keys. We are locked out of the house, okay? Thankfully, I can't see it. Mom, I didn't lock this window. So, get inside. All right, hold on. I need you to go inside and unlock the door, got it?
Shanna
Uh-oh, oh no, she's sending this two-year-old inside to unlock the door. Uh-oh. This is going to go well.
Laura
Yeah, this kid is like, I don't know, two and a half maybe? Oh yeah, definitely.
Speaker 1
Okay, grab a chair.
Shanna
Grab a chair. Take it to the door. Oh my God. She wants him to take the chair to the door to unlock it. He just stands on the chair at the table.
Speaker 1
I need you to focus. Focus.
Shanna
Oh, he's moving the chair. Grab the chair, take it to the door. Oh, he's getting closer, distracted. Oh, he's a fuzz. Oh, a rock. In the chair and pushing. Oh my God. I love this. Come on, buddy. Save the day. Nope. Now he's sitting on the chair. You got a rock. OK. Well, I thank you. Oh my god, now he's distracted by a toy or a stick.
Laura
I think he's not listening. Fireplace tools.
Shanna
Oh, it could be. Oh yeah, he's playing with like a fireplace poker or something and totally not listening to his mother.
Laura
Oh my god, I can't believe she's trying to coach a two-year-old to do this. And like, she's outside in the snow. Like she is freezing her ass off.
Speaker 1
Hold on. Hold on. Hold on. I'm serious. I can't get inside the house.
I can't get through the window. I need you to get the chair.
Shanna
He's sticking his face in this fireplace tool holder.
Laura
Oh my God. I love two year olds. The way he looks at her too, you know, he's like he wants to help, you know, but his brain is just not letting him.
Shanna
He's getting the chair closer. Oh, the rug is in the way. Oh, he's moving the rug out of the way. That's smart. Yeah, I'm very impressed with this kid. Oh, he got the chair to the door. He's standing on the chair. Come on, buddy. Did you get it? Come on, buddy. You got this. You got this.
He's touching the lock.
You're amazing. He got it. Oh my God, he got it. Buddy. Yay.
Laura
Oh, he's so cute. He's so cute. I mean, that's a pickle, right? You're outside in the snow. I could see you calling dad and be like, come back. You have our keys. But she's like, let's make it an adventure out of this. I'm just going to shut my two and a half year old. in through the window and hope for the past.
Shanna
Well, Laura, according to that study, kids, young kids are geniuses, so clearly he's smart enough to do that, right? Yeah, totally.
Laura
Just takes a little bit of distraction. I love the comments too. Someone, the top comment is, Bro had to complete some side quests before completing the mission.
Shanna
My favorite was when he took, like, the fireplace tool holder and just, like, put it up to his face and, like, was sticking his face to the bottom of it. And then he found a rock and had to show it to Mommy. And, oh, that's amazing.
Laura
Yeah. I mean, I love it. I'm so glad she had the forethought to record it. The cynical part of me is, like, could she not, like, was she doing this just for the views? Because, like, could she not squeeze through that window? But, I don't think so. I think she just legitimately couldn't get in and she knew to get it on camera. I mean, I just don't know what plan B was gonna be if he ran off, you know?
Shanna
Oh, true. Yeah, like what if he just disappeared upstairs or something?
Laura
Yeah, I guess you could break the window and run in. Yeah, she knew her son. She knew he'd get there eventually and he did. It was very cute. He did. He's so cute. We'll have to share the link in our show notes so everyone can see the adorableness. But this is from a user if you want to go find it in the meantime. Jessica, G-E-S-I-K, and then six A's after that. A-A-A-A-A. Ah, okay, great. Oh, righty. So yeah, that was my final Internet and Sanity, Shanna. Amazing. Do you have one more for us? I do, but why don't we wait until after the break? Okay.
OK, we are back. And Shanna, do you have one more internet insanity for us? I do.
Shanna
Believe it or not, Laura, this one is also grandma related. Wow, grandmas are having a moment on Big Fat Positive this week. Yeah. So I came across this in an article from Scary Mommy, which is always a delightful read, but it actually also references a TikTok. So there's that as well. I love this so much. This guy, he's probably in his 30s. He does a TikTok explaining how at his grandma's house, she has a ranking board hanging on her wall with magnets of the faces of all 10 of her grandkids and she ranks them from one to 10. Every day she mixes them up depending on a lot of different factors and she just keeps a running tally of how much she loves her grandkids.
Laura
Okay, this doesn't seem aligned with Rye parenting to me.
Shanna
Yeah, I think there's like a funniness to it. Like all her grandkids are adults, first of all.
Laura
Okay, well that makes a difference.
Shanna
That makes a huge difference.
Laura
They're all adults at this point. It'd be pretty rude to say like the three-year-olds in the 10th spot today.
Shanna
I know that would be so sad if they were kids. So the adults find it funny, right? So therefore I find it funny too.
Laura
Okay. Okay. That is a detail. That is a detail I needed to feel less weird about this. Okay.
Shanna
Go on. Yeah. Yeah. There's definitely like a humor about it. And like in this video, the guy's like, okay, so here's my grandma's grand kid ranking board. He's like, I am currently number four. He's like, that's like the highest I've ever been. I just got some new tattoos and he like pulls his sleeve up and he shows like some new ink. He's like, that is not gonna go over well with grandma and grandma comes in and she's like, what's that? And he's like, these are my new tattoos. And she like instantly pulls his face off number four and puts it down to number 10. He's like, damn it. So he went down to the bottom. But I wanted more info about this grandma and what this was all about. So I found some more articles and an interview with her. She's really cute. She's got 10 grandkids. And apparently the number one and two spots are consistently held by the top two grandkids.
And so the interviewer is like, why is the number one person in the number one spot? And she's like, well, she lives across the street from me. She comes over a lot and she helps out a lot. And the number two grand kid is a vet and I love animals. And then they're like, well, who like consistently ranks lowest? And she's like, oh, Ariana. And they're like, why? What does Ariana do? She's like, she doesn't call me enough. She doesn't visit me enough. She works like she's very busy. So it's really like to keep the grandkids in check on like talking to grandma basically and paying attention to her. So it's so cute. And then the interviewer is like, well, what would cause a grand kid to like rise up to the top quickly? She's like, oh, if they get married recently, right to the top. If they have a new baby, they go right to the top, and she's just got this whole system worked out.
It cracks me up so much. And the grandson that did the video, he's so good-natured about it and stuff, and they all think it's funny. But I was just like, oh man, this ranking system is too much.
Laura
That's really funny. I feel like it only works in bigger families because if you have three kids, and you're ranking them consistently, like, that's a recipe for having a real complex. But if there's 10 of them, it's like, okay, look, there's too much competition.
Shanna
Yeah, yeah, exactly. And I think they all feel proud when they have their moment in the spotlight, you know, and like, there's a big event and they get to rise up to number one for a moment, you know, before the granddaughter who lives across the street moves back in. A fun, funny little family thing.
Laura
That is really cute, actually. It started out as like, ew, toxic competition in families and moved on to, oh, this is adorable.
Shanna
Yeah, yeah, totally. Okay, the TikTok is from a user named Dan LaMorte, L-A-M-O-R-T-E. We'll link to it. And here, I'll send you the video so you can just watch it really quick and see what I'm talking about with this little ranking board.
Laura
Okay, let's see. I love that it says family and a cute script at the top. She has square headshots of each kid. Kid, they're all adults, like you said. Oh, grandma. Grandma hates the tattoos. She is so upset.
This is too cute. Oh my goodness. I love her. Yeah. Yeah. She's lovable. Well, that's aspirational. If I ever have more than like six grandkids, I know what I'm doing with my time. Exactly. A good way to spend your retirement.
Yeah.
Laura
Except for I should have had kids younger because like I don't know if I'm going to be alive for my adult grandchildren to be around. Probably should have had kids earlier than 36 and 38. to do that, but we'll see.
Shanna
Well, you can be a hundred years old running your little ranking board, Laura.
Laura
Fair enough. Fair enough. All right. Well, that was a fun segment. It was. But I do think it's time to move on to our BFPs and BFNs. All right.
Okay, so we close every show with a Big Fat Positive or a big fat negative from the week. Shanna, tell us what you got.
Shanna
I have a BFN. I think it's an N. Maybe it's like a BFH, like a BF, hmm.
Okay.
Shanna
I'm not sure.
I had this realization recently that I've kind of been thinking about. And when I first became a parent, I soaked up parenting books, right? Like I loved the Janet Lansbury books. I've read things like how to talk so your kids will listen to those books. I just read so many books and I gained so much knowledge on parenting and whenever I would come across like a a stumbling block in my parenting, I would go back to one of my books or I'd buy a new book and read it. And I realized recently that I stopped doing that. I don't know, maybe a year or two ago. And I feel like I'm fatigued by learning about parenting. Techniques and skills and I'm curious why like clearly I still have obstacles and problems like I swear for two years I've been like ooh I'm gonna read that book on siblings or ooh I'm gonna you know learn about siblings from that Dr. Becky course I bought two years ago and just
Don't do it. Fatigue is like the word that comes to mind. Like I'm fatigued about diving deep into this stuff and I'm curious why, right? I'm like, okay, so maybe I feel like I've topped out my mental load of being the person responsible for learning about all of this stuff all these years and I'm just like over it. Or is it that parenting advice has kind of turned into this social media like nuggets, nugget eyes parenting thing? You know what I mean? Like I follow a lot of parenting teachers and stuff on Instagram and TikTok and all that. So I get like these little bite size pieces of parenting advice and it's always coming at me. And so maybe that's why I feel fatigued by it. But then I'm like, am I really, am I really learning enough from those little nuggets? I don't know. I feel conflicted about all of this. And I don't know.
I just wanted to ask you if you feel a similar fatigue about, you know, learning about parenting techniques and stuff.
Laura
Yeah, I would say another factor might be the fact that we have a weekly podcast where we talk about parenting that takes up a lot of our time. Yeah, true. I mean, because I kind of feel similarly, I feel like, so I have this book called Parent Effectiveness Training, I think is what the title is. And I've read the intro and that's it. And like, I need to read it because it's come highly recommended. And it's the same thing. I just like, Every time I try to read it, I'm like, I just want to think about something other than parenting. You know, when I have time to sit and read a book, I want to think about something else. You know, I want to like go into a different world or learn something completely unrelated because so much of my time is absorbed by parenting that it's like, is it going to creep into this time too? You know?
Shanna
Yeah. Yeah, definitely. I've definitely looked at my Kindle library and been like, ooh, I should read The Whole Brain Child. That would be really good for me. And then I'm like, ooh, but that other book looks a lot more interesting. And I just don't do it.
Laura
I just don't crack them open anymore. I do think there's also the thing which you're ahead of me on this, which is like once you've had a kid for sort of enough years, you don't feel like a rookie anymore. You know what I mean? And when you have a new baby, you're like so fucking out to see with it. You know, you're just like, they gave me this baby and I'm supposed to know what to do with it. But when they can talk back to you and tell you what's on their mind, it becomes less mysterious. That's not to say there's not more to learn, but it's not like staring at this baby that's just crying at you and you have no idea why and you need help. Common sense starts to take over in a little bit. I'm with you. I want to keep reading more because I feel like a lot of the Rai parenting stuff is really good for young kids, but both your kids and Augie are aging out of pure Rai. Yes.
You need different techniques. Like you said, I've picked up snippets from Dr. Becky and all these parenting resources online, but I need a more coherent
Straightforward guidebook. So yeah, I think I'm with you on this and maybe this is a good reminder to just suck it up and set some time aside.
Shanna
Yeah, yeah, because I definitely feel like there are some things I could learn and some new things. perspectives and techniques I could bring into my parenting, just not today.
So yeah, that's my BF for the week, just something that's been on my mind. What about you? What do you have for us this week?
Laura
I have a BFP, technically, but I think it's going to gross you out.
Which are disposable emesis bags?
Shanna
Oh, yeah. Okay. Yeah. Not my favorite topic, but I can see how that would be useful. Go on.
Laura
So I did not know these existed outside of the hospital, basically. until I saw a TikTok from Casey Davis, the struggle care slash domestic blisters creator who wrote the book How to Keep House While Drowning, and she's just awesome. Just randomly on her TikTok a few months ago, I saw that she says that she has created little bins that are like illness survival bins. I can't remember if that's exactly what she called it, but basically they're little like Tupperwares. That contain within them all the stuff you need for different types of illnesses so she had like a you know flew bin which has like Kleenex and Tylenol and the thermometer and all the stuff you need for that and then she had a stomach bug kit. And in the kit, it was, you know, Tylenol. And I, you know, if I was doing it, I'd probably put those suppositories in. And then she had these disposable emesis bags.
And I was like, that is smart. Because whenever anyone in the household is, you know, throwing up, I have to like scramble to find something to put under their mouth. Right? Like I have to like find a... I think I used like the Easter bucket once, you know, because I was so gross, right? But it was there and it was plastic and it could contain it. And so when I saw these, I was like, oh, that's genius just to have on hand. And so I went and impulse bought them. And I remember when they arrived from Amazon, Corey was like, what are these? I'm like, 25 MSS bags just in case we ever need them. Hopefully we don't. And he's like, okay, whatever. And this week, they came in so handy because not only are they like disposable and clean and all that stuff, but they like pack down into like a flat little disc so you can put them in your pocket.
So I just had one in my pocket at all times this week. So I could like whip it out and put it underneath his little chin in case he started like looking like he was going to throw up, which was often the only downside is that he figured out what they were like for after the first couple of times, right? And so I was paranoid and not wanting to like clean up the house anymore. So anytime he'd start looking a little green, I'd of course whip it out. And little Sebastian, he'd see and he'd go, no. No and push it away.
No, no because he and we had to tell him like it doesn't make you throw up, baby It's just there in case you do we could be like no Like you didn't like it but he associated it with being sick Yeah, but we just had one like we had one stashed in every little corner of the house and one of my pocket at all times and I cannot tell you how much cleaning that saved me during the stomach bugs so I Highly recommend them.
Shanna
They are super cheap if you buy them in bulk online and yeah smart day I definitely need to do that and get some of those because with me and my phobia whatever I can do to make it all like Cleaner and quicker the better so doing that today
Laura
Yes, and they're like blue. The ones I have are like blue and semi opaque. So it's not like you're even looking at it really. You just like twist it up and get rid of it. Beautiful. Yeah, just what you need. So yeah, I mean, technically mine was a BFP. It may not sound like it, but it was.
Shanna
Yes, yes, I can see where you're coming from with that for sure. But I do think that wraps up our episode. However, I have a five star review to read. Okay, let's hear it. This review is from low hops on Apple podcasts. The title of the review is a long overdue review five stars. I feel so blessed to have found this podcast in 2020 before I even started my TTC journey. Now I've listened to every single episode and have a nine month old daughter. Shanna and Laura feel like friends at this point. They provide laughs advice and stories of pregnancy and parenthood that have helped keep me grounded insane throughout the last few years. An absolute must listen for anyone who wants to add a little joy and levity in the midst of the chaos of parenting. I never want the show to end. Oh, thank you so much. Aw, that's such a great review. That was such a wonderful review.
And listeners, take it from low hops. It's never too late to leave a review. Even if you've been listening for three years, four years, how long have we been doing this show, Laura? 200 years, I think at this point. Yeah. It's never too late to leave us a five-star review if you love the show. So please do us a favor, head over to Apple Podcast, leave us a five-star review, tell other prospective listeners what you love about the show. It really helps new listeners take a chance on Big Fat Positive and helps grow our audience and community. And we appreciate it so much. As an added bonus, you might hear your review read on our show. Also, listeners, do you have any internet insanities you've come across recently that you want to share with us? We want to hear them. Laura, where can everyone reach us?
Laura
We're on Instagram, Facebook, and our favorite TikTok at BFP Podcast. We have a website, bigpatpositivepodcast.com. If you want to send us an email, you can always throw a voice memo into that email. We love those. Just send it to contact at bigpatpositivepodcast.com. And if you want to join the coolest group of people on the internet, search Facebook for Big Fat Positive Community. It's a private group, so you need to request to join and answer the two membership questions so we know you're not a robot. And once we verify your humanity, you will be sent straight through to the amazing, wonderful, brilliant conversations we're having in there.
Shanna
Our show is produced by Laura Birek, Shanna Micko, and Steve Yager. Thank you so much for listening, everyone. Have a Big Fat Positive Week. Bye. Bye.

